Politics
Churchill, the Greatest Briton, Hated Gandhi, the Greatest Indian || By RAMACHANDRA GUHA
Published
8 years agoon
Exactly a century ago, Mahatma Gandhi began his first all-India movement against British colonial rule. Winston Churchill was, and continued to be, unimpressed by those efforts.
Within his homeland, Winston Churchill’s colossal contribution to saving his people from Hitler eclipses all else, and he is widely regarded as the greatest Briton of all time. So it came as something of a surprise when a senior Labour Party politician recently described him as a “villain” for having ordered troops to fire on striking workers in the Welsh town of Tonypandy in 1910. The claim provoked vigorous denunciations from prominent politicians, as well as more sober reflections in op-ed pages. When the dust settles, as it soon must, Churchill will revert to being the figure of sanctity that he has always been.
Within his homeland, that is. Outside the United Kingdom, Churchill has always had a decidedly mixed reputation. This is especially so in India, my own country, where his undying opposition to freedom for Indians is both well known and widely deplored. As is his hatred for Mahatma Gandhi, a figure he repeatedly mocked, callinghim (among other things) a “malignant subversive fanatic” and “a seditious Middle Temple lawyer, now posing as a fakir of a type well known in the East, striding half-naked up the steps of the Viceregal palace.”
Churchill and Gandhi met once, in November 1906. The Englishman was then the undersecretary of state for the colonies; the Indian, a spokesman for the rights of his countrymen in South Africa. Back then, Gandhi wore a suit and tie, as befitting a lawyer trained in London. It is not clear whether Churchill remembered their meeting when, in the early 1930s, he began attacking Gandhi, whose Salt March had made waves around the world and established him as the preeminent leader of India’s struggle for freedom from British rule.
At the time, Churchill was out of office and seeking to rebuild his political career by working up British sentiment in defense of the empire. By the time he was prime minister a decade later, leading the fight against the Nazis, he remained implacably opposed to independence for Gandhi’s people. His senior cabinet colleague Leo Amery recalled how Churchill had once referred to Indians “as a beastly people with a beastly religion.” He might have added that their leader was, in his opinion, the beastliest of them all.
In August 1942, Gandhi launched his last great popular struggle, the Quit India Movement. He was immediately arrested and taken to a prison in Poona (now known as Pune). Churchill also convinced himself that Gandhi was acting on behalf of the Axis powers. Archived British documents show that in September 1942, Churchill wrote to Amery, “Please let me have a note on Mr. Gandhi’s intrigues with Japan and the documents the Government of India published, or any other they possessed before on this topic.” Three days later, Amery replied, “The India Office has no evidence to show, or suggest, that Gandhi has intrigued with Japan.” The “only evidence of Japanese contacts [with Gandhi] during the war,” Amery continued, “relates to the presence in Wardha of two Japanese Buddhist priests who lived for part of 1940 in Gandhi’s Ashram.”
The Quit India Movement was marked by protests across the country. A British government report blamed Gandhi for the violence that followed his arrest. Gandhi was hurt by the accusations, since he had always preached and practiced nonviolence. When the Raj refused to retract the accusations, Gandhi began a three-week fast in prison. Once again, Churchill developed unfounded suspicions about Gandhi, this time convincing himself that the Indian was secretly using energy supplements, and therefore not really fasting.
On February 13, 1943, Churchill wired the viceroy, Lord Linlithgow: “I have heard that Gandhi usually has glucose in his water when doing his various fasting antics. Would it be possible to verify this.” Two days later the Viceroy responded, “This may be the case but those who have been in attendance on him doubt it, and present Surgeon-General Bombay (a European) says that on a previous fast G. was particularly careful to guard against possibility of glucose being used. I am told that his present medical attendants tried to persuade him to take glucose yesterday and again today, and that he refused absolutely.”
As Gandhi’s fast entered its third week, Churchill again wired the viceroy:
Cannot help feeling very suspicious of bona fides of Gandhi’s fast. We were told fourth day would be the crisis and then well staged climax was set for eleventh day onwards. Now at fifteenth day bulletins look as if he might get through. Would be most valuable [if] fraud could be exposed. Surely with all those Congress Hindu doctors round him it is quite easy to slip glucose or other nourishment into his food.
By this time, the viceroy was himself exasperated with Gandhi. But no evidence showed that he had actually taken any glucose. So the viceroy now replied to Churchill in a manner that stoked both men’s prejudices. “I have long known Gandhi as the world’s most successful humbug,” Linlithgow fumed, “and have not the least doubt that his physical condition and the bulletins reporting it from day to day have been deliberately cooked so as to produce the maximum effect on public opinion.” Then, going against his own previous statement, the viceroy claimed that “there would be no difficulty in his entourage administering glucose or any other food without the knowledge of the Government doctors”—this when the same government doctors had told him exactly the opposite. “If I can discover any firm of evidence of fraud I will let you hear,” Linlithgow wrote to Churchill, adding, “but I am not hopeful of this.”
This prompted an equally disappointed reply from Churchill: “It now seems certain that the old rascal will emerge all the better from his so-called fast.”
In 1943, Lord Wavell replaced Linlithgow as viceroy. The prime minister warned Wavell “that only over his [Churchill’s] dead body would any approach to Gandhi take place.” Then he joked that Wavell had “one great advantage over the last few Viceroys”: They “had to decide whether and when to lock up Gandhi,” whereas this viceroy “should find him already locked up.”
Wavell, however, stood against Linlithgow and Churchill and believed that India should become independent. He released Gandhi from prison in May 1944. When World War II ended a year later and a Labour government came to power in Britain, Churchill’s reactionary policies were set aside, and formal negotiations for a transfer of power began. The British departed the subcontinent in August 1947, dividing it as they left into the separate, sovereign nations of India and Pakistan. Gandhi was murdered by a Hindu fanatic in January 1948.
These facts are well known. What is not is that Churchill’s dislike of Gandhi persisted even after British rule in India had ended and his adversary had died.
In 1951, Churchill published an installment of his war memoirs, The Hinge of Fate, and made an astonishing charge against Gandhi. The former prime minister claimed that the Indian had conducted his 1943 fast “under the most favourable conditions in a small palace” and that “the most active world-wide propaganda was set on foot that his death was approaching.” Then Churchill wrote, “It was certain, however, at an early stage that he was being fed with glucose whenever he drank water, and this, as well as his own intense vitality and lifelong austerity, enabled this frail being to maintain his prolonged abstention from any visible form of food.”
“In the end,” Churchill continued, “being quite convinced of our obduracy he abandoned his fast, and his health, though he was very weak, was not seriously affected.”
The publication of this volume of The Hinge of Fate created an uproar in India. Gandhi’s secretary, Pyarelal, and his doctor, B. C. Roy, wrote angry letters to Churchill, dismissing the Englishman’s claims as canards. Gandhi had refused to take glucose at any time during his fast—which Linlithgow had written to Churchill—even though a government doctor had warned him that he might die if he did not. Further, Gandhi had always said that his fast would last exactly three weeks.
The Indian press also responded with fury, archival materials show. The Tribune, a newspaper based in the northern-Indian city of Ambala, said Churchill’s charges had been refuted by those who had firsthand knowledge of Gandhi’s fast, and put Churchill’s baseless attacks in a broader context. “Mr. Churchill’s remarks only betray his lack of understanding of the Mahatma’s character and his general ignorance about this country,” the paper wrote. “Mr. Churchill is a great war-time leader. But no man is more insular in his outlook. He has yet to realise that the people of Asia, Africa and the Middle East are entitled to a life of their own. He still thinks in terms of the hegemony of the world by Anglo-Saxon peoples.”
Even sharper in its criticism was the now-defunct Indian News Chronicle. Its editorial on September 27, 1951, titled “Churchilliana,” said the former British leader’s memoirs were full of myths and misstatements, of which the calumnies against Gandhi were representative. Churchill’s “entire political career,” the paper thundered, “is a record of political opportunism, inconsistency, and downright wickedness.” Calling him a “friend of reaction” and “a high priest of British imperialism,” the editorial ended:
Mr. Churchill is incorrigible, hopelessly out of date, and is getting unpopular day by day. His memoirs might be read for their grandiloquent phraseology, bombast, and nineteenth century English, but no student of history will find his version of recent history a safe guide. The odds are that these memoirs, in course of time, will be rescinded to the dustbin. And as for his malicious attacks on Mahatma Gandhi, we are certain that they will deceive no one. Long after Churchill and his memoirs have been forgotten, humanity will continue to regard Gandhiji as a beacon of peace; and cherish his memory with reverence even as they cherish the memory of Jesus, Buddha and Socrates.
The Hindustan Times’ response was less polemical, but arguably more effective. The paper was then edited by Gandhi’s son Devdas, who dispatched a reporter to locate Major General R. H. Candy, the British doctor who had attended to Gandhi during his prison fast. Asked to comment on Churchill’s allegations, Candy, then living in retirement in rural Hampshire, confirmed that he had indeed advised Gandhi to take glucose, but that Gandhi had refused. “From my knowledge of Mr. Gandhi,” he said, “I am convinced that he would not willingly have taken glucose or any other form of food” during his fast. Churchill’s response to these corrections is unknown.
Recent works by Indians have blamed Churchill for the Great Bengal Famine of 1943, in which more than 2 million people died. As prime minister, Churchill could have done more to ensure speedy supplies of grain to the affected areas. But to call him a war criminal and a mass murderer, as some polemicists have done, is surely hyperbolic.
That said, there is no question that Churchill had an intense dislike of Indians in general, and a pathological suspicion of one Indian in particular. His venomous and long-lasting hatred of Gandhi shows that this great Briton could sometimes think and act like a small-minded parochialist.
This essay has been adapted from Ramachandra Guha’s book Gandhi: The Years That Changed the World, 1914–1948.
RAMACHANDRA GUHA is a historian based in Bengaluru.
Politics
APM campaign: SSACO mocks Makinde, Adekanmbi over poor turnout
Published
4 days agoon
November 15, 2026By
Mega IconThe Senator Sharafadeen Alli Campaign Organisation (SSACO) has mocked Governor Seyi Makinde and the governorship candidate of the Allied Peoples Movement in Oyo State, Bimbo Adekanmbi, over the poor turnout recorded at the party’s campaign flag-off in Oyo town on Saturday.
The organisation described the attendance at the rally as a sign of the alleged declining popularity of the party and predicted that Adekanmbi would struggle to secure widespread support in the 2027 governorship election.
The rally, held at Durbar Stadium, Oyo, was organised to formally kick-start Adekanmbi’s governorship campaign and that of other APM candidates contesting National and State Assembly seats.
However, SSACO said the turnout fell short of expectations, despite months of planning and mobilisation across the 33 local government areas of the state. It also pointed to the absence of some candidates as evidence of what it described as the party’s weak grassroots appeal.
In a statement issued on Sunday by its Director of Media and Publicity, Bisi Oladele, the organisation said the rally had exposed the political challenges confronting Makinde and Adekanmbi ahead of the next general elections.
SSACO alleged that the governor was deploying state resources to support Adekanmbi’s ambition and pursue what it described as an unrealistic presidential project.
It said, “The embarrassing poor attendance at the Oyo State APM governorship campaign flag-off in Oyo town on Saturday was another confirmation that Oyo State people have rejected the party’s governorship candidate, Hon. Bimbo Adekanmbi, and his sponsor, Governor Seyi Makinde.”
The organisation argued that the alleged poor performance of the state government in agriculture, youth development, industrialisation and rural infrastructure could affect the political fortunes of the governor’s preferred candidate.
It also accused the Makinde administration of neglecting rural roads and damaged bridges, blaming the situation on what it described as the paralysis of local government councils.
SSACO further said the people of the state would not forget what it called the failure of the government to deliver meaningful democratic dividends during its seven-and-a-half years in office.
The statement added, “Governor Seyi Makinde told the little crowd that Nigerians would show the APC what it had never seen before in the 2027 elections.
“Ironically, the people of Oyo State used Saturday’s campaign to tell Governor Makinde what he was not ready to hear: Your time is over; therefore, your stooge does not stand a chance.”
The organisation said its principal, Senator Sharafadeen Alli, would adopt a different approach to governance if elected governor in 2027.
According to SSACO, Alli’s Oyo AHEAD agenda would prioritise functional local government administration, cooperation with the Federal Government and efforts to address what it described as the shortcomings of the Makinde administration since 2019.
Politics
Makinde clueless despite N359bn allocations, failed to grow Oyo economy – Alli’s group
Published
4 days agoon
November 15, 2026By
Mega IconThe Senator Sharafadeen Alli Campaign Organisation (SSACO) has launched a scathing attack on Oyo State Governor, Seyi Makinde, describing him as clueless about economic development and accusing him of wasting the opportunity provided by increased federal allocations to industrialise the state, create jobs and improve the living conditions of residents.
The organisation said Makinde’s recent interview on a national television station exposed his inability to explain how his administration had translated the huge financial resources available to the state into productive economic activities, despite receiving about N145bn and N214bn in federal allocations in 2024 and 2025 respectively.
In a statement by its Director of Media and Publicity, Bisi Oladele, SSACO said it was shameful that the governor, despite benefiting from the increased allocations arising from President Bola Tinubu’s economic reforms since 2023, could not point to a clear industrialisation strategy capable of creating jobs and generating wealth for the people.
It accused Makinde of attempting to downplay the significant increase in federal allocations while arguing that what mattered was building a productive economy.
The organisation, however, challenged the governor to explain why the increased resources at his disposal had not translated into a thriving industrial sector, stronger business activities and improved economic opportunities across the state.
“It is shameful that Governor Makinde tried in vain to downplay the triple and sometimes quadruple federal allocations accruing to Oyo State since 2023 by reason of President Tinubu’s reforms, insisting that what matters is productive economy.
“He has failed to apply the funds appropriately to create the right environment for industrialisation and activities that will provide jobs and enable the people of Oyo State to create wealth.
“It is a sign of cluelessness to have huge funds and have no idea how to use them to enable productive economic activities. If President Tinubu’s reforms deliver the money, should he be the one to teach Governor Makinde how to utilise it for the benefit of the people of Oyo State?” the statement asked.
SSACO also accused the governor of mismanaging the state’s electricity intervention, alleging that N8.5bn was spent on a failed electricity project while he continued to criticise the Tinubu administration over the country’s power challenges.
It said Makinde had failed to take advantage of the Electricity Act 2023, signed by President Tinubu, which opened up opportunities for states to participate in electricity generation and distribution.
According to the organisation, states such as Lagos, Ekiti and Abia have taken steps to explore the opportunities provided by the legislation, while Oyo has failed to make comparable progress in providing reliable electricity for industries, businesses and households.
The campaign organisation described the situation as a contradiction, accusing Makinde of criticising the Federal Government over electricity supply while failing to deliver an effective alternative for residents and businesses in his own state.
“It is disheartening that Governor Makinde spent N8.5bn of those increased federal allocations on a failed electricity project while he criticises President Tinubu for not fixing electricity.
“While states like Lagos, Ekiti and Abia have taken advantage of the Electricity Act 2023 to liberalise electricity generation and distribution, among others, Governor Makinde has failed woefully to act in the same manner to provide electricity to industries, other businesses and households.
“It is laughable that a man who cannot reset the Oyo State economy is grandstanding as a man who can reset Nigeria. Oyo State people definitely deserve a better governor than Makinde,” SSACO said.
The organisation said Senator Sharafadeen Alli, if elected governor in 2027, would reverse what it described as the economic failures of the Makinde administration through his Oyo AHEAD agenda.
It listed the proposed policies to include the establishment of a state electricity regulatory framework, investment in solar energy, provision of low-interest funding for the organised private sector, revival of the Free Trade Zone and the establishment of a N10bn youth development fund.
SSACO said the proposed interventions would stimulate industrial activities, support businesses, expand employment opportunities and create an enabling environment for wealth generation.
It further argued that Alli’s alignment with the Federal Government would position Oyo State to attract greater developmental benefits and investment opportunities.
The organisation urged residents to make the right political choice in the 2027 governorship election, insisting that the state needed a governor with the vision and capacity to convert available resources into tangible economic development.
Politics
Ogbomoso Political Earthquake: Makinde Loses Ex-CoS, 32 APM Chieftains to APC
Published
1 week agoon
November 10, 2026By
Mega IconThe immediate past Chief of Staff to Oyo State Governor, Seyi Makinde, Segun Ogunwuyi, on Tuesday led 32 other political chieftains of the Allied Peoples Movement to the All Progressives Congress, in a major political realignment in Ogbomoso.
The defection, which took place at Oja’gbo, in front of Soun Ogunlola Hall, attracted a large crowd of APC members and supporters, forcing a disruption of vehicular movement in the area for more than three hours.
The defectors included Alhaji Rasak Gbadegesin, popularly known as Agbeti; Timothy Oyeniyi; Alabi Olateju; Dr Banji Folaranmi; Isaiah Adegbite; Peter Oyetunji; and the APM Chairman in Ogbomoso North Local Government Area, Jimoh Sikiru.
Also in the group were council secretaries, chiefs of staff, supervisory councillors and special assistants serving in Ogbomoso North, Ogbomoso South, Surulere and Ogo-Oluwa local government areas.
Speaking on behalf of the defectors, Ogunwuyi said they joined the APC to contribute to the party’s growth and strengthen its chances in the 2027 general elections.
He expressed confidence that the APC would win convincingly in Ogbomoso, adding that the new members were ready to work for the party’s success.
The APC State Chairman, Chief Moses Alake Adeyemo, welcomed the defectors and assured them of equal opportunities in the party.
He urged them to close ranks with existing members and work towards the victory of APC candidates in the 2027 elections.
Explaining his decision to leave the APM, Folaranmi accused the party of being run as a one-man organisation, alleging that Makinde was the only person effectively running its affairs.
The APC governorship candidate, Senator Sharafadeen Alli, described the defection as a significant blow to the APM, saying the departure of Ogunwuyi and other political figures showed that the party was losing influential members.
He said, “For the likes of Hon. Segun Ogunwuyi, Alhaji Rasak Agbeti and other politicians of substance to abandon Governor Makinde, it means a lot.
“I use this medium to tell the few ones who are still there to leave now and join us in the APC.”
The development is expected to give the APC a boost in its grassroots mobilisation across Ogbomoso and neighbouring communities ahead of the 2027 elections.
It also comes as political parties intensify their preparations for the governorship contest, with Alli seeking to consolidate the APC’s influence across the state and challenge the political structure of the ruling party.
The defection is particularly significant for the APC’s Oyo South political calculations, as Ogunwuyi and other defectors are expected to bring their political networks and grassroots connections into the opposition party.
Among the APC leaders who attended the rally were former senators Ayoade Adeseun and Brimoh Yusuf; former Speaker of the Oyo State House of Assembly, Olagunju Ojo; former APC state chairman, Akin Oke; Kemi Alao-Akala; Bashiru Akataapa; Aderemi Adepoju; and Abiodun Adeyemo, popularly known as Obadoba.
Members of the Oyo APC State Executive Committee were also present.
The Director-General of the Senator Sharafadeen Alli Campaign Council, Asiwaju Yemi Aderibigbe, and his deputy, Sola Ogunbode, attended the event.
Other political figures at the rally included the APC deputy governorship candidate, Adesoji Adedeji; Hannah Ogunesan; Segun Odebunmi; and Olamijuwonlo Alao-Akala.
MEGAICON TV
APM campaign: SSACO mocks Makinde, Adekanmbi over poor turnout
Makinde clueless despite N359bn allocations, failed to grow Oyo economy – Alli’s group
Oyo: Makinde scrambles as defections threaten political structure
Trending
-
News4 weeks ago2027: Alli, Oseni Tour Ibarapa, Seek Support for APC Candidacies
-
Opinion4 weeks agoDoctors’ Strike and the Price of Human Life | By Olusegun Hassan
-
Metro4 weeks agoAlli Visits Slain APC Member’s Family, Pledges Support for Pregnant Widow
-
Education3 weeks agoOseni Charges Nigerian Graduates to Prioritise Character, Excellence